Clinical trial: prefilled trays and whitening strips work equally well when used for an hour a day
- A Brazilian randomised trial compared prefilled hydrogen peroxide whitening trays with whitening strips in 120 participants.
- There was no difference in tooth colour change between trays and strips when each was used 60 minutes a day.
- Cutting tray wear to 30 minutes a day produced less whitening.
- Tooth sensitivity was low in all whitening groups, and no severe side effects were reported.
The Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry published on 27 October 2026 a randomised clinical trial from São Paulo State University (UNESP), Brazil, comparing two popular at-home teeth whitening methods using hydrogen peroxide.
Trial design
120 participants were split into three groups of 40, each treated once daily for 7 days:
Also read: FDA warns consumers about unauthorized clear aligners sold without a dentist's supervision
- Prefilled trays, 11% peroxide, 30 minutes a day.
- Prefilled trays, 11% peroxide, 60 minutes a day.
- Whitening strips, 9.5% peroxide, 60 minutes a day.
Tooth colour was measured with a shade guide and a spectrophotometer for up to 21 days, along with sensitivity, gum condition and satisfaction.
Results
- Both 60-minute groups achieved greater colour change, with no significant difference between trays and strips.
- Cutting tray time to 30 minutes produced less whitening, and the gap persisted at 21 days.
- Tooth sensitivity was low and similar across groups.
- Gum irritation was more frequent with 60-minute trays but mild and transient.
- Participants were satisfied with both systems, including their comfort and fit.
Limits
The trial was relatively small with only 21 days of follow-up, so it does not show how long the colour lasts.
Source: Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry via PubMed
This story is relayed from the source named above; responsibility for its content rests with the original source.
FAQ
Which works better for teeth whitening: prefilled trays or strips?
The Brazilian trial found no difference in tooth colour change between prefilled trays and strips when each was used 60 minutes a day.
Is 30 minutes a day enough for teeth whitening with prefilled trays?
Using prefilled trays for 30 minutes a day produced less whitening than 60 minutes a day after 7 days.
Does peroxide teeth whitening cause sensitivity?
Tooth sensitivity was low and similar across all teeth whitening groups in the trial.
What peroxide strength was used in the teeth whitening trial?
The trial used 11% hydrogen peroxide in prefilled trays and 9.5% in whitening strips.
Does teeth whitening irritate the gums?
Gum irritation was more frequent with 60-minute tray use, but it was mild and transient.



