Jonas Salk: "There is no patent. Could you patent the sun?"
- Asked in 1955 who owned the patent on the polio vaccine, Jonas Salk answered: the people, and there is no patent.
- He said it days after his vaccine was declared safe and about 90% effective against paralytic polio.
- Salk never profited from it, though lawyers later concluded the method was probably not patentable anyway.
"Well, the people, I would say. There is no patent. Could you patent the sun?"
That was Jonas Salk's reply when broadcaster Edward R. Murrow asked him on television in 1955, "Who owns this patent?" Few lines in modern medicine have travelled as far.
Also read: Hippocrates: "Life is short, and Art long"
The moment behind the line
In the early 1950s polio was the summer terror of American families, a disease that could leave a healthy child paralysed or breathing through an iron lung. On April 12, 1955, Thomas Francis, Salk's mentor and the director of the huge field trial, announced that the vaccine was safe, potent and about 90% effective against paralytic polio. Salk became a national hero overnight.
So when Murrow raised the question of ownership, Salk's answer reflected how he saw his work: a vaccine that protects children belongs in as many arms as possible, as fast as possible. According to the Salk Institute, he never patented it and never earned money from it.
The fuller story
History adds a twist. The National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis and the University of Pittsburgh did look into a patent, not to make money, since they had already agreed to give the method to drug makers for free. Their lawyers concluded the techniques were probably not novel enough to patent. Even so, Salk's words became a lasting symbol of the idea that some medical breakthroughs are too valuable to be treated as property.
What came next
Mass vaccination began almost immediately. By 1959 the Salk vaccine had reached about 90 countries, and within 25 years domestic transmission of polio had ended in the United States.
Sources: Science History Institute: Jonas Salk and Albert Bruce Sabin, Salk Institute: Jonas Salk, Slate (2014) — The real reasons Jonas Salk didn't patent the polio vaccine
This story is relayed from the source named above; responsibility for its content rests with the original source.
FAQ
Who said "Could you patent the sun?"
"Could you patent the sun?" was said by Jonas Salk in 1955, answering Edward R. Murrow's question about who owned the patent on the polio vaccine.
Did Jonas Salk patent the polio vaccine?
Jonas Salk did not patent the polio vaccine and made no money from it; lawyers for the National Foundation later judged the method probably not patentable.
How effective was the Salk polio vaccine?
On April 12, 1955 the Salk vaccine was declared safe and about 90% effective against paralytic polio.



